Standard consumer epoxy kits look like a reasonable alternative to professional installation at the point of purchase, but their chemistry differs from professional-grade products in ways that surface within a few years of real-world use. The concern behind the question “does garage floor coating peel over time” is valid, and it depends almost entirely on the product installed and how the slab was prepared.
Consumer epoxy has lower adhesion strength than professional systems, cures in a narrower moisture window, and produces a softer surface more susceptible to the thermal stress created by daily vehicle traffic. These are chemistry differences, and that product gap is a primary reason how long an epoxy garage floor lasts can land anywhere in a fifteen-year range.
The performance difference becomes clearest when you look at the full cost picture over time. A DIY epoxy kit that costs a fraction of professional installation but requires replacement in five years carries a higher ten-year cost than a professional polyaspartic system.
High-performance systems like polyurea and professional polyaspartic are engineered for adhesion, chemical resistance, and thermal flexibility in ways that consumer products are not, and that engineering is what delivers the longer end of the lifespan range consistently. For homeowners weighing all their options and researching garage floor coatings in depth, the real question is which cost structure makes more sense across a decade of actual use.